3 min readChoosing an Agency

How to Choose an SEO Agency: Questions to Ask and Red Flags

Choosing an SEO agency is harder than choosing most marketing suppliers, because results take months to show and much of the work is invisible. By the time you can tell a weak agency from a good one, you may have paid for half a year. This guide is about telling them apart before you sign. It assumes you have already decided SEO is the right channel; if not, start with our SEO vs PPC comparison.

Know Which Kind of SEO You Need

"SEO" covers several quite different jobs, and agencies tend to be stronger at some than others:

  • Local SEO: getting a business with premises or a service area into map results and local searches. See our guide to local SEO.
  • Technical SEO: fixing the way a site is built so search engines can crawl and understand it, which matters most for large and ecommerce sites. See our guide to technical SEO.
  • Content-led SEO: building pages that answer what buyers search for, the core of most B2B and service-business campaigns.
  • Authority building: earning links and mentions from other sites, often through digital PR.
  • AI search visibility: being cited by ChatGPT and Gemini, and in Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, increasingly part of the brief. See our guide to GEO.

Build your shortlist around the kind you need. A brilliant local SEO consultant may be the wrong choice for an online shop with 20,000 products, and the reverse is just as true.

What a Good SEO Proposal Contains

Before you compare prices, compare what each agency has actually looked at. A proposal worth taking seriously will include:

  • Specific observations about your site, such as pages competing with each other, technical problems or gaps in your content, rather than a generic list of services
  • The search terms or topics they would prioritise and why, tied to what you actually sell
  • What they will deliver each month in terms you can check: pages written, fixes made, links earned
  • How they will measure success, ideally in enquiries or revenue, with rankings and traffic as supporting measures
  • A realistic timeline. Most campaigns take four to six months to show clear movement, and longer in competitive markets

Questions to Ask Every SEO Agency

  • Who will do the work? Ask for the names and experience of the people on your account, and whether any of the work is outsourced.
  • How do you build links? Good answers involve content, PR and relationships. Vague answers, or talk of link "networks" and packages, are a warning.
  • What will you need from us? SEO usually needs time from your developer, quick content approvals and access to your experts. An agency that asks nothing of you is unlikely to change much.
  • Can we see a client like us? Ask for a case study in a similar market, and ask to speak to that client.
  • What happens if we leave? The content, accounts and reports should be yours. Our guide to switching agencies lists what to check.

Red Flags

  • Guaranteed rankings: nobody controls Google's results, and Google's own guidance warns against anyone who promises a top position.
  • Prices that look too good: SEO for £150 a month rarely includes more than automated reports. Our pricing guide sets out typical ranges.
  • Secret methods: a good agency will explain what it is doing and why. "Proprietary techniques" that cannot be described usually mean shortcuts that put your site at risk.
  • Reports that only show rankings: rankings for terms nobody searches are easy to win. Ask how traffic and enquiries have moved.
  • Long lock-ins from day one: an initial term of three to six months is reasonable given how long SEO takes; twelve months before you have seen any work is not.

Agency, Freelancer or In-House?

Experienced freelance SEO consultants are often excellent for local and smaller campaigns, and many agencies started as one. An agency makes more sense when you need technical, content and link-building work running at the same time, or cover when someone is away. Larger businesses often pair an in-house SEO lead with agency support; our comparison of in-house teams and agencies covers the costs of each.

Once you have chosen, the first three months set the tone. Our guide to working with a new agency covers what should happen and when.

Find an SEO Agency

Browse SEO agencies in our directory, filter by location and team size, and send the same brief to three of them. Our guide to writing a marketing brief will help you get proposals you can compare.

Ready to Find Your Perfect Agency?

Browse our directory of 800+ UK digital marketing agencies.

Browse Agencies